The Yankees have a lot to address this Winter. I don't think this team is that far off from being a championship team, but the more important issue is all of the expiring contracts... Jeter, Rivera, Ghirardi, Pettitte and some of the short term guys.
The CaptainThe news about Jeter has been around his off-year this year. People keep talking about his .270 batting average, whether or not he can play SS anymore. I think this year is a fluke. It's not a sign of him getting old because he was just one year younger last year. And yes... he can play SS. He's still the best at it. They Yankees infield is all gold glove and have given up the least # of errors in MLB. Jeter needs to come back at all costs. He's the face of the franchise and is a great leader. He's up there as one of the greatest Yankees of all time. The fans would never forgive the organization if he went and played for the Red Sox.
BullpenRivera is 40 years old, but doesn't seem to be losing anything. He's still the best closer in the game, throws 90 mph and faces the toughest batters in the lineup with a 1.* ERA. Resigning him is a no-brainer. If the Yankees fall short on money, Kerry Wood might be the guy to go, although I think they should keep him as much as possible. They should also hold on to Joba despite the off year. Everyone else is expendable.
PitchingObviously, CC is still on contract. Unfortunately, so is Burnett. Pettitte is still a question mark as he decides year-by-year whether he's going to retire or not. He had an 11-2 season because of injury and ended with a strong ALCS performance. Those aren't signs of someone who should retire... but then again, Mike Mussina went out on a 2-win season, the best of his career. Many say Pettitte will return if the Yankees are able to sign Cliff Lee. Besides CC, Andy, Mo and Wood, the rest of the pitchers on the roster had bad years. Hughes had the record, but not the ERA. Some players took steps back this year, like AJ and Joba. Let's not forget Chan Ho Park in the first half! So it wasn't a surprise that coach, Dave Eiland was fired yesterday.
CatchingPosada is still on contract, but people keep bringing up what position he will play. I think he's still fine as catcher. There has been no one to hand the torch over. Cervelli is close, but doesn't have the offense and is not as experienced with the entire pitching staff. Like this year, he'll probably see limited minutes as catcher. Hopefully Cervelli can really improve soon though.
ManagerWhen the Yankees fail to get to the World Series, the immediate reaction is to fire the manager. Every move he makes gets second-guessed the next day... if he's wrong. People forget that the Yankees have the best record in the AL, despite the terrible bullpen and injuries to key players. So I think Ghirardi should come back as well. I believe in keeping the team together for the most part. Failing in the ALCS is no reason to start from scratch.